Home > News & Reviews > Foo Fighters

Foo Fighters - Concrete and Gold (Album Review)

Friday, 22 September 2017 Written by Simon Ramsay

Setting aside the fact this boundary-pushing release from the Foo Fighters is already being praised and pilloried in equal measure, you have to applaud Dave Grohl. Well aware of the creative coma many stadium headlining bands slip into, he’s spent the last decade trying to make sure his gang don’t follow suit. Such artistic restlessness has largely been successful, so why does ‘Concrete and Gold’ flatter to deceive?

For 2011’s ‘Wasting Light’ the Foos recorded in their leader’s garage, intent on capturing a back-to-basics youthful energy.  Its follow-up, ‘Sonic Highways’, saw them embark on an ambitious trip around some of America’s most famous recording studios, resulting in a lauded audio visual project. This time they may have decided to record in a single studio like a proper band, but that’s where normalcy ended.  

Enter Greg Kurstin, a producer whose CV includes collaborations with Adele and Sia. Combine his markedly different style with appearances from Justin Timberlake, Paul McCartney, Boyz II Men’s Shawn Stockman and Alison Mosshart of the Kills, and it’s clear they haven’t so much pushed the envelope as shot it into orbit.

Grohl may have proclaimed this record as “Motörhead's version of ‘Sgt. Pepper’, or “Slayer making ‘Pet Sounds’,” but the overall aesthetic is psychedelic indie-pop melded with every classic rock artist the band grew up on.  

The elaborate arrangements, unusual time signatures, bombastic orchestration and an array of lush, complex harmonies on display are immediately reminiscent of, among others, Queen and the Beatles. Whether it’s the short but grandiose T-Shirt, punky fury and disorienting riffage that propels La Dee Da or epic suburban angst of The Sky Is A Neighbourhood, there’s an impressive density of textures here that’s unlike anything they’ve done before.

When records are this layered and challenge expectations, they can often take a few spins to banish initial disappointments and click. ‘Concrete and Gold’ is the opposite. Once the immediate razzle dazzle of such detailed craftsmanship wears off, its lustre fades surprisingly swiftly. Those enjoyable new flavours, and the special guest appearances, start to feel like window dressing: gimmicks employed to glam up a preponderance of solid, but largely unmemorable, material.

Take Make It Move and the title track. The former has a wicked groove but a truly forgettable hook buried beneath its Sgt. Pepper affectations – and Timberlake’s backing vocals are so indistinct even his most ardent fan wouldn’t recognise him. The latter’s Black Sabbath-meets-Pink Floyd mash up can’t elevate an awful dirge.  

It’s Run, though, that epitomises this record’s main problem. Unleashing a frenzied guitar motif, it then drools out a hook that’s dreamlike and plodding. When bands invert the quiet verse, explosive chorus dynamic, said refrain has to be killer otherwise the song loses momentum. It’s the album in microcosm: its superb parts just don’t cohere into a similarly outstanding whole.

It’s disappointing that, although noble of intention and artistically brave, this record is a backwards step after several solid outings. It offers a lot of stylistic gold but a dearth of long-lasting, concrete substance.

Let Us Know What You Think - Leave A Comment!

You May Also Like:

Tremonti - A Dying Machine (Album Review)
Mon 25 Jun 2018
Mark Tremonti is now such a revered guitarist that he could release a triple album of self-indulgent fretboard gymnastics and his fans would still lose their minds. And yet, as evidenced by this conceptual LP of superbly sculpted rock and metal anthemics, he’s no slouch in the songwriting department either. ‘A Dying Machine’ is a defiant coming of age moment for a ‘side band’ who are rapidly outgrowing the tag, standing equal to anything from the Alter Bridge and Creed man’s back catalogue.
Ghost - Prequelle (Album Review)
Tue 05 Jun 2018
Photo: Mikael Eriksson Ghost have returned to engulf the world in hellish flames on their fourth album and most scintillating statement to date, ‘Prequelle’. But this time around the masked metallers wreak havoc through music far closer in spirit to ABBA and Duran Duran than Pentagram and Blue Öyster Cult.
Ghost Confirm September Royal Albert Hall Show
Mon 25 Jun 2018
Ghost will play London’s Royal Albert Hall this autumn.
Black Stone Cherry Announce December UK Arena Tour
Mon 11 Jun 2018
Photo: Harry Reese Black Stone Cherry will tour the UK at the end of the year.
Enter Shikari Announce Marathon UK Tour
Wed 11 Jul 2018
Photo: Tom Pullen Enter Shikari have announced a massive UK tour.
Enter Shikari To Release 'Content' Photozine and Bootleg Series CD For Charity
Thu 28 Jun 2018
Photo: Tom Pullen Enter Shikari have announced a new release for charity.
Fields of the Nephilim Announce Autumn UK Shows
Fri 08 Jun 2018
Fields of the Nephilim have announced a handful of UK shows celebrating 30 years of their song Moonchild.
Guns N' Roses Share 1986 Demo Version Of November Rain
Thu 28 Jun 2018
Guns N' Roses have shared a demo of November Rain.
< Prev   Next >