Home > News & Reviews > Dashboard Confessional

Dashboard Confessional - Crooked Shadows (Album Review)

Tuesday, 27 February 2018 Written by Jennifer Geddes

Dashboard Confessional forget the importance of being earnest on their seventh release, ‘Crooked Shadows’, which is troubled by confusing production choices and lacklustre lyrics. Still, some elements that made the emo veterans so engaging over a decade ago remain.

Back in the early 2000s, the band took ‘A Mark, A Mission, A Brand, A Scar’ to No.2 on the Billboard chart, while Chris Carrabba displayed total conviction when leading audiences in singing lyrics like: “And the plaster dented from your fist, in the hall where you had your first kiss.”

His music may have sounded a million miles away from emo’s hardcore roots, but the connection was that the music was direct, challenging, passionate and very much part of a dedicated community. Very little of that formula remains on ‘Crooked Shadows’.

Here Carrabba has been reduced to singing “We got the radio pumping jams” on Belong, which also sees him team up with EDM producers Cash Cash. The closing acoustic track, Just What To Say, tries to recapture the vulnerable intimacy of the band’s better years, but fails to land the emotional punches. “And every day, I take a white page and try very hard to know just what to say,” Carrabba sings.

Only the opening track, We Fight, has any power behind it. Originally written by Carrabba about his love of the scene, he now feels like its generic punk stance has taken on a grander meaning in the current political climate “We never learned to keep our voices down,” he sings. “No, we only learned to shout. So we fight our way in. And we fight our way out.”

The album as a whole sees Carrabba trying on all sorts of different musical styles. About Us is a stadium anthem reminiscent of earlier Fall Out Boy. Heart Beat Here is an acoustic-driven track with Mumford & Sons-style backing vocals. Catch You, meanwhile, has a very confusing mesh of ‘80s influences that includes prominent bass, synth melodies and a little shimmering guitar, none of which really gel that well. What is consistent throughout, though, is that is that Carrabba remains an engaging performer.

This is the band’s first release with their new label, Fueled By Ramen, who are in the business of making Top 40 hits with bands like Paramore, Panic! At The Disco and Twenty One Pilots. Bands that Carrabba helped pave the way for. Nine years is a long time to be out of the game if you’re looking for a chart smash, and today’s teenagers won’t necessarily be familiar with Dashboard Confessional. If this is an attempt to introduce the band to a new generation, then Carrabba seems a bit lost in the modern pop landscape.

Let Us Know What You Think - Leave A Comment!

You May Also Like:

Thanks For Listening, Thanks For Understanding: The Hold Steady Come Alive In London
Wed 14 Mar 2018
Illustration: Thomas Norton There are easier jobs than singing along with Craig Finn, particularly when he’s in this sort of mood. His arms are spread wide, proselytising like the old days. He shimmies and shakes. His guitar, never his closest friend, swings at his waist like an invitation to a party he’s only half into. His words pour out and are yelled back by everyone who can keep pace; anyone who hasn’t already screamed their voice to shreds. It’s good to see him back in a bar band, baby.
An Extra Thrill and a Twist: Introducing Marine
Tue 03 Apr 2018
Marine’s music pushes the listener into a dreamy state of consciousness with a blend of anarchically melodic instrumental arrangements and a female chorus of trill, tuneful vocals.
Yo La Tengo - There's A Riot Going On (Album Review)
Wed 21 Mar 2018
Since they shuffled onto the stage over 30 years ago, New Jersey’s Yo La Tengo have established themselves as one of the most enduring lo-fi bands on the east coast, creating a catalogue of distinctive shoegaze that has impressed with its subtle diversity.
The Breeders - All Nerve (Album Review)
Thu 22 Mar 2018
Photo: Marisa Gesualdi It takes a short while to get your head around the new album from the Breeders as it sounds like something very familiar. After multiple listens, it turns out that the answer is…the Breeders. ‘All Nerve’ sounds just like the Breeders.
Coming of Age: Press To MECO Forge Ahead on 'Here's To The Fatigue'
Tue 10 Apr 2018
Press to MECO are one of a number of interesting, slightly off-kilter alt-rock bands bubbling under in the UK at the moment, with their new record ‘Here’s to the Fatigue’ pushing them into ambitious new territory.
Albert Hammond Jr. - Francis Trouble (Album Review)
Fri 16 Mar 2018
Photo: Autumn de Wilde “What the music says may be serious, but as a medium it should not be questioned, analyzed or taken too seriously.”
Hop Along - Bark Your Head Off, Dog (Album Review)
Thu 12 Apr 2018
Photo: Tonje Thilesen When confronted with an empty canvas, there’s always a temptation to fill every inch of it; to purge yourself of ideas, to remake and remodel. On their second album, ‘Painted Shut’, Hop Along didn’t have that option. Their time in the studio came with a full stop attached to it, so they had to work fast and clean. The dense, layered approach of their debut, ‘Get Disowned’, was set aside in favour of economical indie-rock songs that had the happy byproduct of pushing their melodies, and Frances Quinlan’s remarkable voice, to the fore more than ever before.
The Decemberists - I'll Be Your Girl (Album Review)
Tue 20 Mar 2018
Photo: Holly Andres On their eighth studio album, ‘I’ll Be Your Girl’, the Decemberists have taken a substantial risk. To a large extent, their folky, quirky core has disappeared and in its place you’ll find something unusual: synthesizers. In the words of frontman Colin Meloy, they experimented with “a lot of weird keyboards”.
< Prev   Next >