Home > News & Reviews > American Football

American Football - American Football (Album Review)

Friday, 22 March 2019 Written by Ben Gladman

After releasing their self-titled debut album in 1999, and promptly splitting up, American Football became a cultural touchstone. They were synonymous with the intelligent side of emo, having created a template that would be imitated throughout the new millennium: complex, intertwining guitar parts, unconventional rhythms, and melodramatic lyrics that chronicled heartbreak and uncertainty with a sort of smug collegiate literariness.

The band were quickly mythologised in their absence, and while their reunion tour and subsequent sophomore album (in 2014 and 2016 respectively) garnered plenty of attention, some were left disappointed. LP2 felt like a tilt at their old style without the magic that infused every song on their debut.

American Football’s newest record (again self-titled, and from here referred to as LP3) does everything that LP2 did not. It takes the band’s best features and pushes them in stunning new directions, experimenting with structure and texture while exploring fresh lyrical themes.

From the opening track, it is clear that things have changed. Compared to their debut, this album is a more reflective affair. Instead of the iconic up-tempo guitar riff that launched LP1, Silhouettes drifts in with the chiming of bells and a bass drone that hints at the darkness to come.

It takes 85 seconds for the first drums and guitars to enter, a decision that highlights this album’s biggest success: its spaciousness. For a band with a reputation for hyperactive complexity, here American Football let their songs breathe in a way they never have before, developing ideas with patience.

It’s a sound that accentuates the lyrical themes of weariness and aging; frontman Mike Kinsella sings of “denouements” and “slow retreats”. Twenty years removed from American Football’s beginnings, he is older and wiser. His writing is wiser too, and Elizabeth Powell (from Land of Talk) and Hayley Williams (of Paramore) have been drafted in to add a new dimension to the vocal performances, trading lines and harmonies in inventive and engaging ways.

That’s not to say that American Football have changed too much. The real highlights of this album are still the guitar parts. Every production decision is calculated to foreground their beauty and delicacy, shrouding the clean arpeggios in a shimmering layer of reverb. Often three or four parts play against and around each other in a style that would become overwhelming if not for the carefully paced ebb and flow of each song. For example, Every Wave to Ever Rise strips back its layers one by one until just bass and vocals remain—when the guitars finally return you no longer take their beauty for granted, but appreciate every little detail in Kinsella and Steve Holmes’ performances.

At times, though, the lyrics can feel heavy handed. Kinsella has always had a penchant for melodrama, and to some extent it’s a part of the genre, where touches of hysteria only add to a sense of nostalgia for an immature yet brighter youth. But, despite the band’s maturing sound and new lyrical topics, the delivery has remained stuck in the past in a way that jars. Lines like, “I have become uncomfortably numb”, do not soar with the rest of the mix, but fall flat like a bad punchline. American Football are at their best when they let their instruments do the talking. Fortunately for us, they do that throughout a wonderful addition to their discography.

Let Us Know What You Think - Leave A Comment!

More Reviews from Ben Gladman

Related News

American Football Share New Song Every Wave To Ever Rise Featuring Elizabeth Powell
Thu 28 Feb 2019
Photo: Atiba Jefferson American Football have shared a new track, Every Wave to Ever Rise.
American Football Share New Track Uncomfortably Numb Featuring Hayley Williams
Tue 22 Jan 2019
American Football have shared another preview of 'LP3', due out March 22.
American Football Release Video For 'LP3' Opener Silhouettes
Tue 08 Jan 2019
American Football have unveiled the video for Silhouettes.
There Is Fun Stuff and Cool Stuff and There Can Be Resistance: Martha Talk 'Love Keeps Kicking'
Tue 02 Apr 2019
One of life’s dirtiest tricks is the way it slowly erodes the time we have to do the things we love. In response we have nights spent on either side of a low stage, sweat flying and words being wrenched from hoarse throats. “When we’re on tour and playing shows I’m like: ‘This is me’. And then I quickly get back into normal, boring work,” Martha bassist Naomi Griffin says.
Martha - Love Keeps Kicking (Album Review)
Wed 10 Apr 2019
Martha’s approach to pop music falls somewhere between kitchen sink realism and wild escapism. Over the course of two LPs and a slew of excellent singles the indie-punk quartet, who hail from Pity Me, close to Durham in the northeast of England, have cemented a reputation as a melodically savvy, socially conscious band capable of telling us the truth and then helping us to forget about it.
PUP - Morbid Stuff (Album Review)
Thu 11 Apr 2019
Photo: Vanessa Heins Since the release of their explosive debut in 2013, PUP have hurtled along a knife-edge between joy and despair with such velocity that it’s been impossible to look away.
Charly Bliss Unveil Video For New Track Hard To Believe
Wed 10 Apr 2019
Charly Bliss have shared a new track.
PUP Share Two New Tracks Ahead Of UK Tour
Fri 22 Mar 2019
Photo: Vanessa Heins PUP have shared two new tracks.
< Prev   Next >