Home > News & Reviews > Chris Stapleton

Chris Stapleton - From A Room: Volume 2 (Album Review)

Thursday, 07 December 2017 Written by Simon Ramsay

Whenever an artist releases a swift follow up to their previous record that includes material culled from the same sessions, any excitement is often curtailed by the nagging concern you’re about to be served reheated leftovers. 

Guns N’ Roses' ‘Use Your Illusion’ records were crammed with filler and, even now, fans still attempt to create one definitive collection from their best tracks. Bruce Springsteen’s ‘Human Touch’ was eclipsed by ‘Lucky Town’, and Metallica’s ‘Reload’, which landed a year after ‘Load’, was full of material that belonged on the cutting room floor.

So how has Chris Stapleton bucked the trend when, at least on the surface, ‘From A Room: Volume 2’ seems to be a bit of a mishmash? The answer lies in both the quality of the material and how it’s been fitted together to produce a cohesive album that’s thematically removed from its predecessor.

If ‘Volume One’ was predominantly focused on the complexity of loving relationships, this effort is centred on an individual’s struggles in an increasingly trying world.

Scarecrow in the Garden is a classic folk song that tells the story of a man whose grandparents emigrated to the USA from Northern Ireland and ran a thriving farm. Much like John Mellencamp’s Scarecrow, modern hardships have left the narrator struggling to sustain it and the song closes with the chilling image of him holding a bible in one hand and a shotgun in the other.

Drunkard’s Prayer, meanwhile, is a visceral confession from a tortured alcoholic, and the achingly soulful Nobody’s Lonely Tonight finds two strangers whose faith in love has been destroyed seeking solace in emotionless hook ups.  Elsewhere, the acoustic, ruminative Simple Song depicts a blue collar storyteller who’s content with his existence because, framed against the quotidian hardships of family members less fortunate than him, he realises how lucky he is.

Sometimes, strong material doesn’t make the cut first time around because it’s too similar to another track or is contextually out of step with the rest of the record. The boot-stomping Hard Livin’ – where an off-kilter phased guitar riff reflects the aging narrator’s struggle to maintain his wild side – occupies comparable lyrical ground to the previous album’s Up To No Good Livin’. Likewise, the rocked up Midnight Train To Memphis – which is markedly different than the bluegrass version Stapleton recorded with the Steeldrivers – not only feels musically reminiscent of Second One To Know, but its story of an imprisoned man battling to survive is conceptually more appropriate here.

What works so well about this album, though, is the way its darker content is bookended by two upbeat, redemptive covers. Millionaire, originally recorded by Kevin Welch, and Pops Staples’ Friendship are luxuriously tuneful and given extra depth by Morgane Stapleton’s heavenly harmonies. They leave us in little doubt that Stapleton, although painfully aware of human fallibility and existential torment, believes the key to negotiating all that ails us is to form bonds that strengthen our will to overcome.

Dual records always attract arguments about which is best. On a song-by-song basis, ‘Volume One’ is marginally stronger. But in terms of its broader, deeper storytelling, ‘Volume 2’ is the more interesting album.

Let Us Know What You Think - Leave A Comment!

You May Also Like:

'Hate Is A Really Rich Well To Draw From': Lice Talk 'It All Worked Out Great'
Fri 06 Apr 2018
“Support us? We’re gonna be supporting you, mate. You come to this city you’re gonna learn the meaning of support.” That’s what Joe Talbot told Alastair Shuttleworth when they first met in Bristol three years ago. Shuttleworth, an English student moonlighting as a music writer, had interviewed the Idles frontman earlier in the evening and now, with a few beers in his belly at an afterparty, was asking whether his band, Lice, could open one of their shows.
Hot Snakes - Jericho Sirens (Album Review)
Wed 21 Mar 2018
Photo: Rick Froberg Few corners of the music world subscribe to the law of diminishing returns quite like reunion albums. They are, broadly, to be treated with suspicion. What are the motives behind them? Does each note contained within sound like a dollar sign rolling around in cartoon eyes? Do the band care? Do we care?
The Magic Gang - The Magic Gang (Album Review)
Tue 20 Mar 2018
Photo: Dan Kendall There’s nothing edgy about the Magic Gang’s self-titled debut. It’s not offensive, it’s not abrasive, it’s not cynical and it certainly isn’t controversial. It’s lacking in a number of seemingly crucial qualities possessed by many classics. And yet that’s precisely why the record feels as fresh as the summer breeze it so often evokes.
Mid 30s Angst: Mastersystem's Scott Hutchison on Using The Past To Undersand The Present
Thu 05 Apr 2018
Sega started phasing out the Master System in the late ‘80s. That’s just how it goes with consoles. It’s always about what’s new and next. But you can still find them, knocking about under a film of dust in an attic or perched next to an ancient Nintendo on a completist’s shelf.
Mount Eerie - Now Only (Album Review)
Wed 21 Mar 2018
Mount Eerie’s Phil Elverum is a musician unlike almost any other. His music, lacking in any perceptible pop structure, plays like a stream of consciousness; raw, without embellishment, and completely devastating. Following the death of his wife, Geneviève, Elverum explored his grief through his work, resulting in the release of a critically acclaimed album, ‘A Crow Looked At Me’.
Cardi B - Invasion of Privacy (Album Review)
Fri 13 Apr 2018
One thing is for sure: Cardi B is no one hit wonder.
The Slow Readers Club Share New Single You Opened Up My Heart
Mon 12 Mar 2018
The Slow Readers Club have released a new single.
Nervus - Everything Dies (Album Review)
Fri 16 Mar 2018
The title of Nervus’s sophomore album belies an optimistic streak. ‘Everything Dies’ suggests a bleak outlook and little hope of consolation, but throughout the record vocalist and guitarist Em Foster discusses acceptance, both personal and societal, alongside some frank words about insecurity and the damage done by preconceptions.
< Prev   Next >