Home > News & Reviews > Gone Is Gone

Gone Is Gone - Echolocation (Album Review)

Wednesday, 11 January 2017 Written by Alec Chillingworth

A group of moderately well-known musicians hang out and form a band. The internet goes mad, the hype train chugs through Supergroup Central and you think the result’s going to match the respective members’ day jobs. More often than not, though, such expectation ends with you listening in woeful denial. “He was really good in Faith No More, so this must be genius,” you think. But no, be honest, you don’t like Tomahawk’s ‘Anonymous’ album.

Mastodon’s Troy Sanders rode the train first-class with members of Soulfly, Dillinger Escape Plan and the Mars Volta for Killer Be Killed and has now decided to make a return journey with three other fairly talented gents: Troy Van Leeuwen, guitarist with Queens Of The Stone Age, A Perfect Circle and Failure; Tony Hajjar, At the Drive-In’s sticksman; and Mike Zarin, a renowned composer. Together, they are Gone Is Gone.

And the signs were positive. A ‘choo! choo!’ rattled round the ears as their self-titled EP arrived last July. Van Leeuwen’s influence reigned supreme, with the EP resembling a Failure/QOTSA hybrid on which everyone else had a bash and saw what happened. It was kinda upbeat. Fun, even. ‘Echolocation’ takes that and throws a screaming, hog-tied love interest onto the tracks.

A fraction of ‘Echolocation’ exists in an alternate universe where the EP’s character carries through and saves the day. The high-tempo alt-rock of Pawns and Gift have Sanders waxing that characteristically weird vocal and Van Leeuwen turning in an off-kilter, wiry guitar line that’s more At The Drive-In than the new At The Drive-In track. And, y’know, Sanders basically doing QOTSA basslines is pretty decent.

The album opens deceptively well, too. Zarin conjures a Hollywood-worthy blanket of ambience on Sentient, luring you in before entering an absolute pain feast, with chugging downstrokes ringing on the strings and everything fuzzed up like Mastodon in a fur coat.

The eclecticism stretches to the end of the record – completely missing the middle, but we’ll get to that – with the final two songs. Resolve plays like a world music/post-‘Heritage’ Opeth mash-up and the title track’s simple snare and bass drumbeat provides the building blocks for a pretty sizeable stab at prog.

These successful experiments aside, Gone Is Gone’s debut LP suffers because it can’t decide what it’s supposed to be. Dublin’s ominous clanging adds nothing to what is essentially a soundscape piece, the chin-stroking antics of Colourfade fail to evoke any true wine-sniffing introspection and Resurge’s QOTSA-isms shuffle along without a memorable hook. There are 12 songs here and about half of them get lost in the ether.

‘Echolocation’ is four veteran musicians, all very competent, clutching at straws instead of driving that bloody train out of harm’s way. Slow Awakening’s eventual swell shows that this group has potential to really nail that alt-rock/prog crossover, but this record is disappointingly limp considering the men behind it and the strength of last year’s EP. So that love interest, trussed up on the tracks? Yeah, they got run over.





Let Us Know What You Think - Leave A Comment!




You May Also Like:

Forget The Barriers: Goat Girl And The Power of Subverting Expectations
Tue 22 May 2018
Photo: Holly Whitaker Expectations are constantly being placed on Goat Girl, and they just keep quietly subverting them. The band were hyped by London’s music press before they had released their debut single, while a narrative grew around them as a political garage-rock band that was part of a growing scene in south London. They then signed to Rough Trade, and 18 months later their self-titled debut album was released. Here they finally have an opportunity to let the music speak for itself.
How To Be a Real Adult: Common Holly on 'Playing House' and Finding Your Place
Tue 15 May 2018
Photo: Sean Mundy  “We’re all pretending to be adults on a fairly constant basis.” Brigitte Naggar tells it like it is. Her thoughtful, considered debut album as Common Holly, ‘Playing House’, was released in October last year, and although it jogs down the well-trodden break up path, she covers the difficult ground through sparse guitar textures, unexpected math-rock production and truly relatable twentysomething lyricism.
Hip-hop, Not Easy Listening: Lewis Parker On 20 Years of 'Masquerades & Silhouettes'
Thu 07 Jun 2018
For people of a certain generation, English producer Lewis Parker is best known for working with Ghostface Killah and being sampled by Joey Bada$$. Flitting between London and New York, Parker has made his name as one of hip-hop's most respected underground heads, renowned for his impeccable groove-based beats.
Journey of a Wild Heart: Introducing Kashena Sampson
Thu 31 May 2018
She may have been mentioned by Rolling Stone magazine in the same breath as Stevie Nicks, and already had her music compared to Linda Ronstadt, Bobbie Gentry and Jim Croce, but Kashena Sampson is capable of standing on her own two feet. Her debut album, ‘Wild Heart’, showcases a singer-songwriter whose artistic authenticity and integrity is increasingly rare in Nashville these days.
Enjoy the Balance: Collective Soul's Will Turpin Shines on 'Serengeti Drivers'
Tue 05 Jun 2018
Every now and then an album arrives from out of nowhere and instantly brightens up your day. Like rays of sunshine breaking through the clouds, ‘Serengeti Drivers’ – the debut solo album from Collective Soul bassist Will Turpin – is quite simply an unexpected treat. Bursting to the brim with a melodious mix of pop, rock, Americana, funk, soul and AOR, it’s the kind of record summer was invented for.
Timing Is Everything: Davey Newington Talks Boy Azooga's Debut LP '1,2 Kung Fu!'
Wed 06 Jun 2018
Photo: Stella Gelardi Malfilatre More haste, less speed. It’s a lesson a lot of us learn the hard way, and one that has shaped Davey Newington’s trajectory with his latest musical project, Boy Azooga.
Middle Kids - Lost Friends (Album Review)
Fri 11 May 2018
‘Lost Friends’, the debut album from Sydney indie-rockers Middle Kids, is a future soundtrack to an indie movie about lost millennials. The band are able to perfectly capture a feeling of intense insecurity through a retro Instagram filter.
Dear Nora - Skulls Example (Album Review)
Thu 31 May 2018
Did Katy Davidson need to bring back Dear Nora? When the project was placed on the shelf in 2008, it had just a handful of records to its name and a presence within the world of west coast DIY indie. Those who would miss it would miss it hard, but most wouldn’t blink an eye. Davidson moved on, enjoying a decade-long spell with Key Losers and Lloyd & Michael while also taking on session and producing work. So, the question remains: why bring back Dear Nora?
 
< Prev   Next >